top of page

New vs. Used Guitars: Making the Right Choice

For aspiring musicians and seasoned players alike, the decision to purchase a guitar is a significant investment. With a plethora of options available in both the new and used markets, determining whether to buy a new or used guitar can be a daunting task. Each option offers its own set of advantages and considerations, ranging from price and condition to playability and customization. In this comprehensive guide, we will delve into the factors that prospective buyers should consider when weighing the merits of new and used guitars.

Understanding the Pros and Cons of New Guitars

New guitars, straight from the manufacturer, hold undeniable appeal for many musicians. They have never been played and are ripe for “breaking-in”. As we play a new instrument it becomes personalized. The wear & tear on each instrument is unique to the player and we grow a bond with our instrument as it ages and our playing matures. Here are some factors to consider when contemplating the purchase of a new guitar:

  1. Instrument Condition

 One of the primary benefits of buying a new guitar is the assurance of pristine condition. With no prior owners or wear and tear, new guitars typically exhibit flawless finishes and unblemished fretboards, providing a sense of freshness and quality assurance. However, a factory set-up may be flawed or might not be the best choice for your playing style. A new instrument will usually need a set-up from a professional, this will add an additional expense to the instrument. Some players may be fine with the factory set-up, but most serious musicians will want to make sure their new instrument is playing well and sounding its best.

  1. Warranty and Support

New guitars often come with manufacturer warranties and customer support, offering peace of mind in case of defects or issues with the instrument. This added layer of protection can be invaluable, especially for novice players who may require assistance with setup or troubleshooting. It is very common for a new instrument to be dropped or scratched and the warranty will definitely come in handy. Instruments are used heavily and often travel with us, so we want to make sure that they are protected.

  1.  Latest Features and Technology

 Purchasing a new guitar allows you to access the latest advancements in guitar design and technology. From innovative pickup configurations to ergonomic body shapes, new guitars often incorporate cutting-edge features that enhance playability and sound quality. Some guitars can even tune themselves! Although most of the typical guitar designs haven’t changed in 80 years, there are many tiny improvements that make new instruments play better and stay in tune. 

  1.  Customization Options 

Many manufacturers offer customization options for new guitars, allowing players to tailor their instruments to suit their unique preferences and playing styles. Whether it's selecting specific tonewoods, finishes, or hardware components, customization empowers players to create their dream instrument from scratch. If you would like to make the instrument your own, this may be something for you to consider. This can help you build a deeper connection with your instrument.

  1.  Resale Value:

While new guitars depreciate in value once purchased, they may hold higher resale value compared to used guitars in similar condition. Collectors and enthusiasts often prefer new, limited-edition models or signature instruments, making them potentially more desirable on the secondary market.

Exploring the Advantages of Used Guitars

While new guitars offer undeniable allure, the used market presents its own array of benefits and considerations. Many guitarists prefer vintage instruments for their unmistakable vibe and weathered look. Some even say that they sound better! Here's why purchasing a used guitar might be the right choice for you:

  1.  Affordability

Perhaps the most compelling reason to buy a used guitar is cost savings. Used guitars are typically priced lower than their new counterparts, making them more accessible to budget-conscious buyers or those seeking higher-end instruments at a fraction of the cost. However, particular vintage models may be even more expensive than their new counterparts. Guitars from the 50s-70s have gone up in value and can be very expensive. Guitars made in the 1980s-2010s however can typically be found at a good value.

  1.  Vintage and Rare Finds

The used market is a treasure trove of vintage and rare guitars that may no longer be in production. Whether it's a classic Fender Stratocaster from the 1960s or a limited-edition Gibson Les Paul, used guitars offer the opportunity to own a piece of musical history with unique character and charm. If you want to play with the same guitars as your heroes, vintage is the way to go.

  1.  Played-in Feel and Tone

One of the distinct advantages of used guitars is the "played-in" feel and tone that develops over time. Unlike new guitars, which may require a break-in period to reach optimal playability, used instruments often exhibit a well-worn patina and seasoned resonance that adds depth and character to the sound. Instruments vibrate, and these vibrations can loosen the wood fibers allowing for a more resonant sound.

  1. Vintage Craftsmanship

Many vintage and used guitars boast superior craftsmanship and attention to detail compared to mass-produced modern instruments. Hand-selected tonewoods, hand-wound pickups, and traditional construction techniques contribute to the distinctive quality and tone of vintage guitars. Some of the woods used in these instruments are no longer available due to environmental protection laws and availability. Handmade craftsmanship is very attractive when compared with modern factory production.

  1. Investment Potential 

While not guaranteed, certain used guitars, especially vintage or collectible models, have the potential to appreciate in value over time. As iconic instruments become increasingly rare, their market value may rise, making them not only a source of musical enjoyment but also a sound investment. Name brand guitars such as Gibson, Martin, and Fender continue to rise in value every year.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between New and Used Guitars

When weighing the pros and cons of new and used guitars, it's essential to consider several key factors that can influence your decision:

  1. Budget:

Your budget will undoubtedly play a significant role in determining whether a new or used guitar is the right choice for you. If you have a limited budget, exploring the used market can offer greater affordability and value for money. However, if budget is less of a concern and you prioritize warranty coverage and customization options, a new guitar may be more suitable.

  1. Playability and Condition:

Assessing the playability and condition of a guitar is crucial, regardless of whether it's new or used. When purchasing a new guitar, you can expect flawless condition and optimal setup, thanks to stringent quality control measures. In contrast, buying a used guitar requires careful inspection to ensure that it meets your standards in terms of playability, intonation, and structural integrity.

  1. Brand Reputation and Model Selection:

Consider the reputation of the guitar manufacturer and the specific model you're interested in. While new guitars offer the latest models and innovations from reputable brands, the used market provides access to a broader range of vintage and discontinued models that may hold sentimental or collector value.

  1. Purpose and Preferences:

Your intended use of the guitar and personal preferences should also inform your decision. If you're a gigging musician who needs a reliable, road-ready instrument, a new guitar with robust construction and warranty coverage may be preferable. Conversely, if you're a collector or enthusiast seeking vintage tone and aesthetic appeal, a used guitar with historical significance may be more appealing.

  1. Test Play and Inspection:

Whether you're considering a new or used guitar, it's essential to test play and inspect the instrument thoroughly before making a purchase. Pay attention to factors such as neck profile, fret condition, electronics functionality, and overall build quality. If buying a used guitar, inquire about the instrument's maintenance history and any modifications or repairs that have been made.

The Choice is Yours

The decision to buy a new or used guitar is a highly personal one that depends on a variety of factors, including budget, preferences, and intended use. While new guitars offer the allure of pristine condition, warranty coverage, and the latest features, used guitars provide affordability, vintage charm, and the potential for investment. By carefully weighing the pros and cons of each option and considering factors such as budget, playability, brand reputation, and personal preferences, you can make an informed decision that aligns with your musical goals and aspirations. Whether you choose to embark on a journey with a brand-new instrument or uncover a hidden gem in the used market, the joy of playing the guitar awaits, ready to inspire and enrich your musical journey.


4 views0 comments


bottom of page